Water and Soil Pollution: Ecological Environmental Study Methodologies Useful for Public Health Projects. A Literature Review

Roberto Lillini*, Andrea Tittarelli, Martina Bertoldi, David Ritchie, Alexander Katalinic, Ron Pritzkuleit, Guy Launoy, Ludivine Launay, Elodie Guillaume, Tina Žagar, Carlo Modonesi, Elisabetta Meneghini, Camilla Amati, Francesca Di Salvo, Paolo Contiero, Alessandro Borgini, Paolo Baili

*Corresponding author for this work

Abstract

Health risks at population level may be investigated with different types of environmental studies depending on access to data and funds. Options include ecological studies, case–control studies with individual interviews and human sample analysis, risk assessment or cohort studies. Most public health projects use data and methodologies already available due to the cost of ad-hoc data collection. The aim of the article is to perform a literature review of environmental exposure and health outcomes with main focus on methodologies for assessing an association between water and/or soil pollutants and cancer. A systematic literature search was performed in May 2019 using PubMed. Articles were assessed by four independent reviewers. Forty articles were identified and divided into four groups, according to the data and methods they used, i.e.: (1) regression models with data by geographical area; (2) regression models with data at individual level; (3) exposure intensity threshold values for evaluating health outcome trends; (4) analyses of distance between source of pollutant and health outcome clusters. The issue of exposure assessment has been investigated for over 40 years and the most important innovations regard technologies developed to measure pollutants, statistical methodologies to assess exposure, and software development. Thanks to these changes, it has been possible to develop and apply geo-coding and statistical methods to reduce the ecological bias when considering the relationship between humans, geographic areas, pollutants, and health outcomes. The results of the present review may contribute to optimize the use of public health resources.

Original languageEnglish
JournalReviews of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology
Volume256
Pages (from-to)179-214
Number of pages36
ISSN0179-5953
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2021

Funding

Acknowledgments This document was produced by “WASABY – Water And Soil contamination and Awareness on Breast cancer risk in Young women”, which received funding from the European Commission as part of the framework of the Health Program (Contract No. PP-2-2016 with the DG SANTE Directorate C). Wasaby Working Group: FRANCE. Registre général des cancers de Poitou-Charentes: Gautier Defossez. Registre des tumeurs de Loire-Atlantique et Vendée: Florence Molinie; Anne Cowpli-Bony. Registre général des cancers de Haute Vienne: Tania Dalmeida. Registre général des tumeurs du Calvados: Anne Valérie Guizard. Registre des cancers de la Manche: Simona Bara. Registre du cancer de la Somme: Bénédicte Lapotre-Ledoux. Registre général des cancers de Lille et de sa région: Sandrine Plouvier. Registre des cancers du Bas-Rhin: Michel Velten. Registre des cancers du Haut-Rhin: Séverine Boyer. Registre des tumeurs du Doubs: Anne Sophie Woronoff. Registre des cancers du sein et des cancers gynécologiques de Côte-d’Or: Patrick Arveux. Registre du cancer de l’Isère: Marc Colonna. Registre des tumeurs de l’Hérault: Brigitte Tretarre. Registre des cancers du Tarn: Pascale Grosclaude. Registre général des cancers de Guadeloupe: Jacqueline Deloumeaux. Registre général des cancers de Martinique: Clarisse Joachim. Registre des cancers de Gironde: Gaelle Coureau. Université de Caen: Josephine Bryere ITALY. Analytical Epidemiology and Health Impact Unit, Fondazione IRCCS “Istituto Nazionale dei Tumori”, Milano: Simone Bonfarnuzzo, Milena Sant. Registro Tumori dell’Alto Adige: Guido Mazzoleni; Fabio Vittadello. Registro Tumori ASL Napoli 3 Sud: Mario Fusco; Maria Francesca Vitale; Valerio Ciullo. Registro Tumori di Palermo e provincia: Rosanna Cusimano; Walter Mazzucco; Maurizio Zarcone. Registro Tumori di Parma: Maria Michiara; Paolo Sgargi. Registro Tumori ASP Ragusa-Caltanisetta: Carmela Nicita; Rosario Tumino. Registro Tumori della Provincia di Siracusa: Ylenia Dinaro; Francesco Tisano. Registro Tumori di Trapani e

UN SDGs

This output contributes to the following UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

  1. SDG 3 - Good Health and Well-being
    SDG 3 Good Health and Well-being

Research Areas and Centers

  • Research Area: Center for Population Medicine and Public Health (ZBV)

Cite this